eISSN: 2299-0054
ISSN: 1895-4588
Videosurgery and Other Miniinvasive Techniques
Current issue Archive Videoforum Manuscripts accepted About the journal Supplements Editorial board Journal's reviewers Abstracting and indexing Subscription Contact Instructions for authors Ethical standards and procedures
SCImago Journal & Country Rank

vol. 16
Interventional radiology

Computed tomography-guided localization for multiple pulmonary nodules: a meta-analysis

Xia Tang
Hong-Mei Jian
Yi Guan
Jie Miao
Xin Liang

Department of Oncology, Fengjie People’s Hospital, Chongqing, China
Department of Endocrine, Fengjie People’s Hospital, Chongqing, China
Department of Second Surgery, Fengjie People’s Hospital, Chongqing, China
Videosurgery Miniinv 2021; 16 (4): 641–647
Online publish date: 2021/03/08
Article file
- Computed tomography.pdf  [0.09 MB]
Get citation
JabRef, Mendeley
Papers, Reference Manager, RefWorks, Zotero


Preoperative computed tomography (CT)-guided localization is commonly employed to facilitate video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS)-guided diagnostic wedge resection of pulmonary nodules (PNs), achieving high rates of successful localization (89.6–100%) and wedge resection (97–100%), with an acceptable rate of complications (8.8–12.6%) [13]. Localization methods usually involve methylene-blue, hook-wire, coils, and radio-labeling agents [17]. Relative to cases without localization, preoperative localization can significantly decrease the need for thoracotomy or VATS anatomical resection when diagnosing PNs [4].

Preoperative CT-guided localization of PNs has a number of advantages over other methods and is widely used for patients with multiple PNs (MPNs) [815]. Several groups have reported their experiences of one-stage localization for MPNs [12, 14, 15]. However, variability in the technical success of such localization has been reported, with studies employing different localization methods (methylene blue, hook-wire, or coils) reporting success rates of anywhere between 88% and 100% [815]. There is a similar degree of variability in the reported complication rates (13–90%) [815]. As such, there is a clear need for other large-scale studies with large datasets to more accurately evaluate the feasibility and safety of preoperative CT-guided localization for MPNs.


The present meta-analysis was conducted with the goal of better evaluating the feasibility, safety, and clinical efficacy of preoperative CT-guided localization for MPNs.

Material and methods

Study selection

PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Library databases were searched for all relevant articles published up to June 2020, using the following search strategy: ((localization[Title/Abstract]) AND (nodule[Title/Abstract])) AND (multiple[Title/Abstract]).

Only studies that satisfied the following criteria were included in the review: (a) studies specifically focused on preoperative CT-guided localization (including staining materials, hook-wire, coil, and radio-label localization) for PNs; (b) patients with MPNs; (c) the diameter of each PN ≤ 30 mm; and (d) studies should report the technical success of CT-guided localization.

Studies were excluded if they were: (a) case reports (only 1–3 cases); (b) conference abstracts; (c) non-human studies; or (d) reviews.

Data extraction

Two investigators independently extracted data from all studies; the corresponding author asked to resolve any discrepancies that arose. Baseline data, demographic information, and treatment-related data were extracted from all studies.

Quality assessment

All studies identified for inclusion in the present meta-analysis had a non-randomized design. Their quality was evaluated using the Newcastle–Ottawa scale [16]. Any study with a score ≥ 5 was deemed to be of high quality [16].


The endpoints of this meta-analysis included the technical success of localization, technical success of wedge resection, and localization-related complications.

MPNs were defined as the number of PNs > 1. Technical failure of localization was defined as the surgeon being unable to visualize the localized materials [9]. When the localization device was dislodged it was also considered a technical failure. Wedge resection was considered to be successful if the target nodule was identified in the wedge-shaped lung tissue [15].


Stata v12.0 software was used to conduct the present meta-analysis. Owing to presumed heterogeneity, a random-effects model was used to calculate the pooled results, with weighting applied according to the inverse variance of the included studies, where heterogeneity was assumed. Heterogeneity of the studies was evaluated using the Q test and measured using the I2 statistic, with I2 > 50% indicative of substantial heterogeneity. Subgroup analysis was used to investigate sources of heterogeneity. P-value < 0.05 was the threshold of significance. Egger’s regression asymmetry test was used to evaluate the risk of publication bias.


Study characteristics

In the initial literature search, 231 studies that were potentially relevant to the present analysis were identified. Of these, 8 were ultimately included in the final meta-analysis. Full details of the study selection process are presented in Figure 1.

Figure 1

Flowchart of the meta-analysis


The overall characteristics of the studies included in the present meta-analysis are shown in Table I. All studies included in the review were retrospective, with scores on the Newcastle-Ottawa scale in the range 6–8. In total, 345 patients with 799 PNs were treated with preoperative CT-guided localization and subsequent wedge resection. In four studies, coil localization was used [11, 12, 14, 15], hook-wire localization was used in 3 [8, 10, 13], and one used methylene-blue localization [9]. The characteristics of the procedures are presented in Table II.

Table I

Characteristics of studies included in the meta-analysis

StudyYearCountryNumber of patientsNumber of nodulesMean age [years]Newcastle–Ottawa score
Iguchi [8]2015Japan358059.98
Tseng [9]2016Taiwan10021759.96
Kadeer [10]2018China76194558
Li [11]2018China5112658.98
Fu [12]2019China194356.36
Sun [13]2019China1634476
Teng [14]2020China3168558
Yang [15]2020China1737Not given6
Table II

Characteristics of procedures

StudyMean lesion sizeLocalized materialsTS of localization (per nodule)TS of localization (per patient)TS of wedge resection (per nodule)TS of wedge resection (per patient)Complication rate
Iguchi [8]0.8 cmHook-wire96%91%Not givenNot given90%
Tseng [9]0.8 cmMethylene blue99%98%100%100%55%
Kadeer [10]0.7 cmHook-wire88%72%96%85%64%
Li [11]0.8 cmCoil96%90%Not givenNot given24%
Fu [12]0.7 cmCoil98%95%100%100%16%
Sun [13]0.7 cmHook-wire100%100%100%100%13%
Teng [14]0.7 cmCoil99%97%100%100%13%
Yang [15]0.9 cmCoil97%94%100%100%Not given

[i] TS – technical success.

Technical success of localization

Data pertaining to the technical success of localization were reported in all studies, and calculated in relation to both nodules and patients. The overall pooled technical success rate based on nodules was calculated to be 97% (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.94–0.99, Figure 2 A). Significant heterogeneity was detected among these studies (I2 = 74.5%, p = 0.001). The overall pooled technical success rate based on patients was calculated to be 92% (95% CI: 0.86–0.97, Figure 2 B), also with significant heterogeneity among the studies (I2 = 77.7%, p = 0.000).

Figure 2

Forest plots of the technical success rate of localization (based on PNs) (A) Technical success rate of localization (based on patients) (B) and complication rate (C)


Technical success of wedge resection

The technical success of wedge resection was reported in 6 studies [9, 10, 1215]. However, because 5 of those studies reported a technical success rate for wedge resection of 100% [9, 1215], it was not possible to pool the results.


The complication rate was reported in 7 studies [814]. The overall pooled complication rate was calculated to be 40% (95% CI: 0.16–0.63, Figure 2 C). Significant heterogeneity was detected among the studies (I2 = 96.3%, p < 0.001).

Subgroup analysis

Subgroup analysis was then conducted for each endpoint variable for the different localization techniques (Table III). Only one study used methylene blue localization [9] and so it was excluded from the subgroup analysis. No significant differences were found in the technical success of localization and the incidence of complications between coil and hook-wire groups.

Table III

Subgroup analyses

VariableTS of localization (per nodule)TS of localization (per patient)Complication rate
Localized materials:

[i] TS – technical success.

Publication bias

Publication bias analysis suggested that the risk of such bias relating to the reported complication rate was low (p = 0.351). In contrast, the risk of publication bias pertaining to the reported technical success rate of localization based on both nodules and patients was found to be high (p < 0.001 and 0.001, respectively).


In the present meta-analysis, the feasibility, safety, and clinical efficacy of preoperative CT-guided localization for MPNs were evaluated. The overall results of our analysis were relatively positive, with a pooled technical success rate of 97% and 92%, respectively, for localization in PN- and patient-based analyses. These results may indicate that it is feasible to simultaneously localize MPNs in a single-stage procedure. However, significant heterogeneity was also detected and it might decrease the reliability of the conclusion. The source of heterogeneity may come from the following factors: (a) all included studies are retrospective in nature; and (b) the included studies used different localized materials. Subgroup analysis demonstrated that the technical success rate for localization was not significantly different for coil and hook-wire groups. These results possibly indicate that the preoperative technical success of localization was not influenced by localization method. Although the study of Tseng et al. [9] was not included in the subgroup analysis due to the use of methylene blue, the technical success rates of localization in PN- and patient-based analyses were 99% and 98%, respectively. Nevertheless, further meta-analysis which focuses on one unique localized material is still required.

The reasons for technical failure using the different localization methods differ. The failure of methylene blue localization was due principally to its diffusive nature [2, 9]. The failure of hook-wire localization was due to it becoming dislodged while coils were occasionally inserted into the lung parenchyma causing the loss of intra-operative localization function [1]. Recently, Zhang et al. [17] reported their clinical experience of computed tomography in combination with intraoperative noninvasive percutaneous ultrasonic localization of PNs with a high technical success rate of 95.6%. Intraoperative ultrasound can provide real-time localization. However, this technique may not localize the MPNs simultaneously.

Although the pooled localization technical success rate was more than 90%, the raw data of the studies included in the review indicated that the majority of studies had a 100% technical success for wedge resection [9, 1215]. VATS-guided wedge resection was usually initially performed following preoperative localization [18]. If localization failed, wedge resection could be performed on tissue identified by palpation of the nodule or coil [1, 9, 12, 14, 15]. Therefore, wedge resection was possible even if preoperative localization failed, although this resulted in wasted surgical time. Fu et al. [12] and Teng et al. [14] found that preoperative CT-guided multiple coil localization could be used to guide single-stage VATS diagnostic wedge resection in patients with MPNs.

Some researchers also performed simultaneous VATS for PNs and synchronous mediastinal/esophageal lesions [1, 19]. Under this condition, if the PNs were metastatic lesions or presented with ground-glass PNs, only wedge resection was enough [1, 18]. Therefore, preoperative CT-guided localization should be performed for such patients to increase the technical success rate of wedge resection.

In the meta-analysis, the pooled complication rate was 40%. This rate is higher than that reported in previous studies (24–29%) regarding preoperative localization for a single PN [11, 20]. It seems reasonable that localization-related complications occurred more frequently in patients with MPNs. However, the significant heterogeneity still requires further trials to confirm this conclusion. Subgroup analysis revealed that the complication rate in the coil group was lower than in the hook-wire group, although not significantly so (18% vs. 56%, p = 0.163). This may be as a result of the limited number of studies. A previous study of coil vs. hook-wire localization for PNs indicated that the total complication rate was lower in the coil group (25% vs. 54%, p = 0.04) [21]. Further meta-analysis which compares the clinical effectiveness between different localized materials is required. Although the pooled complication rate was high in this meta-analysis, the majority of studies reported that most localization-related complications did not influence the subsequent VATS-guided resection procedure [1, 9, 12, 14, 15].

There are a number of limitations to the present meta-analysis. Firstly, all studies included in the analysis were retrospective. In addition, we detected significant heterogeneity in the pooled results. Some variability may be attributable to the many potential confounding variables or covariates not reported in the manuscripts, such as operator experience, the direction of approach, or needle tract depth. Furthermore, the meta-analysis included a variety of different localization methods, thus potentially biasing the results of technical success and complication rate analysis.


The results of the present meta-analysis suggest that preoperative CT-guided localization may be used effectively to guide VATS wedge resection in patients with MPNs. The use of a coil may decrease localization-related complications. Further meta-analysis which focuses on one unique localized material is still required.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.



Fu YF, Zhang M, Wu WB, et al. , authors. Coil localization-guided video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery for lung nodules. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2018. 28:p. 292–7


Gruber-Rouh T, Naguib NNN, Beeres M, et al. , authors. CT-guided hook-wire localisation prior to video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery of pulmonary lesions. Clin Radiol. 2017. 72:p. 898.e7–8.e11


Zhang ZD, Wang HL, Liu XY, et al. , authors. Methylene blue versus coil-based computed tomography-guided localization of lung nodules. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2020. 68:p. 540–4


Finley RJ, Mayo JR, Grant K, et al. , authors. Preoperative computed tomography-guided microcoil localization of small peripheral pulmonary nodules: a prospective randomized controlled trial. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2015. 149:p. 26–31


Iguchi T, Hiraki T, Gobara H, et al. , authors. Transfissural route used for preoperative localization of small pulmonary lesions with a short hook wire and suture system. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2015. 38:p. 222–6


Xia FF, Shi YB, Wang T, et al. , authors. Computed tomography-guided transfissural coil localization of lung nodules. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2020. 68:p. 545–8


Lin MW, Tseng YH, Lee YF, et al. , authors. Computed tomography-guided patent blue vital dye localization of pulmonary nodules in uniportal thoracoscopy. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2016. 152:p. 535–44.e2


Iguchi T, Hiraki T, Gobara H, et al. , authors. Simultaneous multiple preoperative localizations of small pulmonary lesions using a short hook wire and suture system. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2015. 38:p. 971–6


Tseng YH, Lee YF, Hsieh MS, et al. , authors. Preoperative computed tomography-guided dye injection to localize multiple lung nodules for video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery. J Thorac Dis. 2016. 8 Suppl 9:p. S666–71


Kadeer X, Wang L, Zhang L, et al. , authors. Modified hook-wire placement technique for localizing multiple pulmonary nodules. J Surg Oncol. 2018. 118:p. 1188–93


Li F, Chen Y, Bian J, et al. , authors. Preoperative computed tomography-guided microcoil localization for multiple small lung nodules before video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery. Zhongguo Fei Ai Za Zhi. 2018. 21:p. 857–63


Fu YF, Gao YG, Zhang M, et al. , authors. Computed tomography-guided simultaneous coil localization as a bridge to one-stage surgery for multiple lung nodules: a retrospective study. J Cardiothorac Surg. 2019. 14:p. 43


Sun W, Zhang L, Wang L, et al. , authors. Three-dimensionally printed template for percutaneous localization of multiple lung nodules. Ann Thorac Surg. 2019. 108:p. 883–8


Teng F, Wu AL, Yang S, et al. , authors. Preoperative computed tomography-guided coil localization for multiple lung nodules. Ther Adv Respir Dis. 2020. 14:p. 1753466620909762


Yang ZJ, Liang YH, Li M, et al. , authors. Preoperative computed tomography-guided coil localization of lung nodules. Minim Invasive Ther Allied Technol. 2020. 29:p. 28–34


Stang A , author. Critical evaluation of the Newcastle-Ottawa scale for the assessment of the quality of nonrandomized studies in meta-analyses. Eur J Epidemiol. 2010. 25:p. 603–5


Zhang Q, Wang Z, Jiang Y, et al. , authors. The application value of computed tomography in combination with intraoperative noninvasive percutaneous ultrasonic localisation of subpleural pulmonary nodules/ground-glass opacity in uniportal video-assisted thoracoscopy. Videosurgery Miniinv. 2020. DOI: 10.5114/wiitm.2020.101238


Zhong L, Hu W, Li S, et al. , authors. Clinical study of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery wedge resection in early-stage lung cancer by tumor mapping with indocyanine green. Videosurgery Miniinv. 2019. 14:p. 545–50


Zeng L, Zhuang R, Tu Z , authors. Simultaneous uniportal video-assisted thoracic surgery for pulmonary nodules and synchronous mediastinal lesions. Videosurgery Miniinv. 2020. DOI: 10.5114/wiitm.2020.101240


Chen S, Zhou J, Zhang J, et al. , authors. Video-assisted thoracoscopic solitary pulmonary nodule resection after CT-guided hookwire localization: 43 cases report and literature review. Surg Endosc. 2011. 25:p. 1723–9


Rostambeigi N, Scanlon P, Flanagan S, et al. , authors. CT fluoroscopic-guided coil localisation of lung nodules prior to video-assisted thoracoscopic surgical resection reduces complications compared to hook wire localization. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2019. 30:p. 453–9

Copyright: © 2021 Fundacja Videochirurgii This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/), allowing third parties to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format and to remix, transform, and build upon the material, provided the original work is properly cited and states its license.
Quick links
© 2022 Termedia Sp. z o.o. All rights reserved.
Developed by Bentus.