eISSN: 2300-6722
ISSN: 1899-1874
Medical Studies/Studia Medyczne
Bieżący numer Archiwum Artykuły zaakceptowane O czasopiśmie Suplementy Rada naukowa Bazy indeksacyjne Prenumerata Kontakt Zasady publikacji prac
 
1/2015
vol. 31
 
Poleć ten artykuł:
Udostępnij:
więcej
 
 
Artykuł oryginalny

Wpływ ergonomii warunków pracy na występowanie bólów kręgosłupa w odcinku szyjnym u stomatologów

Jędrzej Płocki
,
Dominik Pikuła
,
Joanna Banaś
,
Andrzej Kotela

Studia Medyczne 2015; 31 (1): 35–41
Data publikacji online: 2015/03/24
Plik artykułu:
Pobierz cytowanie
ENW
EndNote
BIB
JabRef, Mendeley
RIS
Papers, Reference Manager, RefWorks, Zotero
AMA
APA
Chicago
Harvard
MLA
Vancouver
 
 

Introduction

The performance of the occupation of a dentist may result in various health hazards, which are related with the effect of many unfavourable physical, chemical, biological, and psychological factors at the workplace [1]. The results of the conducted studies [2] indicate that dentists are an occupational group especially exposed to the occurrence of occupational and para-occupational diseases concerning the musculoskeletal system, associated mainly with a non-ergonomic method of performing work. Dentists most often complain of pain syndromes concerning the lumbosacral and neck regions of the spine, shoulder pain, as well as neuropathies in the hands. In some cases, occupational diseases may be diagnosed, such as humeral epicondylitis (‘tennis elbow’) and carpal tunnel syndrome [2].
In modern dental ergonomics, the principles of teamwork are promoted in order to reduce the overload of the osteoarticular system in a dentist. The physicians share duties with assistants, relegating from 35% to 60% of their activities. This means a decrease of fatigue and the load on the musculoskeletal, visual, and nervous systems in a dentist [3]. The problem of health hazards resulting from the method of performing the occupation of a dentist concerns, among others, the cervical section of the spine. The fact that physicians spend approximately 30–50% of their working time in a leaning position may increase pain complaints [1]. Such a non-physiological position forces an uneven work load on muscles of the anterior and posterior side of the neck, may lead to shallow cervical lordosis, and consequently, to the natural exploitation of tissues and their overloading. This phenomenon may concern intervertebral discs, facet joints, bone tissue, and the spinal ligaments. A forced, non-ergonomic body position, in combination with immobility and long-lasting contraction of muscles, may lead to acidification, fatigue, and muscle pain, while strong pain may even lead to discontinuation of occupational activity by dentists. Increased cervical pain results in prolongation of the working time of many dentists, which additionally contributes to an excessive exploitation of the body. The performance of work by a dentist is associated with intellectual work, and a greater or smaller amount of physical work, mainly static, and physical and mental load are inseparable elements [4, 5].
Dental work covers prophylactic, therapeutic, and rehabilitation activities. In order to cope with these activities the entire dental team should provide this care. The leader of this team is a physician, to whom are subordinated the medium-level dental staff – a hygienist, assistant, and dental technician [6].
Recently, greater attention has been paid to so-called psychosocial factors, i.e. tension, time pressure, responsibility, complexity of work, and its intensity, which may increase pain complaints on the part of the musculoskeletal system. The psychological load of a dentist may be caused by the monotony of work (repeating, to a lesser or greater extent, the same activities), monotypy (repetitive work movements), precision of motor activities (due to the size of the surgical area), necessity to make frequent and difficult decisions (related with the making of diagnosis, course of procedure), and watchfulness (i.e. a state of high concentration of senses, mainly sight and touch) [5, 7]. Dentists are an occupational group exposed to the occurrence of cervical pain; therefore, every physician should know how to arrange their own workplace, and how to work with a patient in a way that is consistent with ergonomic principles. Dentists should pay attention to proper prophylaxis, to avoid leading to exclusion from their occupational life, which may cause financial loss, disorganisation of work in a dental room or an outpatient clinic, and may also be harmful for a patient, while the patient’s wellbeing should be the main goal of the work of a dentist and the entire dental team [7, 8].

Material and methods

The study group consisted of 52 dentists – 33 females (63.5%) and 19 males (36.5%). The completion of a questionnaire was the criterion of enrolment into the study.
The study was conducted using the following methods: an anonymous questionnaire designed by the authors, Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), a modified pain assessment questionnaire according to Laitinen [9], and methods of descriptive statistics.
The questionnaire consisted of 36 items divided into 3 parts concerning: personal data (e.g. gender, age, height, weight, place of work, and duration of employment), work ergonomics (e.g. knowledge of ergonomics, position at work, equipment possessed, help from assistants, methods of work), and pain complaints (among others, intensity of pain, its character, treatment applied, other complaints).
The Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) is a subjective method that allowed determination of the intensity of pain sensation experiences. According to the 10-degree scale, the following intensities of pain were distinguished: 0 – no pain, 1–3 – mild pain, 4–7 – moderate pain, 8–10 – severe pain [10].
A modified questionnaire for the assessment of pain by Laitinen was used for measuring pain according to its intensity and frequency, use of analgesic drugs, and limitation of physical activity [10].

Statistical analysis

Statistical data were analysed using the software Statistica 6.0. While interpreting the results, the degree of statistical significance of the relationships between variables was determined with the use of Pearson’s χ2 test for independence [11]. In this test, the zero hypothesis assumes the lack of a relationship between variables (the variables are independent). An alternative hypothesis is that there is a relationship between variables (the variables are dependent). The value of p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

The results of the study showed that a half of the respondents work 5 days a week, whereas less than 30% work less than 5 days, mainly those aged 46–60 years and over. Young dentists, mainly those aged 30–45 years (21.1%) admitted that they perform occupational activity more than 5 days a week. A similar situation was observed with respect to the number of working hours a week – 28.8% of respondents work more than 41 h, less than 12% have more than 21 patients daily. More than 90% of the dentists in the study (47) declared that they knew the principles of ergonomics, while only 5 dentists did not possess such knowledge.
A small number of respondents (10) perform work in a standing position, 20 – in a sitting position, and the reminder (22) perform work in both standing and sitting positions. Patients are most often provided treatment in a sitting/semi-sitting position (53.8%), sitting and prone position (36.5%), and less than 10% of dentists place their patients in a prone position (Figure 1).
In a group of 25 physicians working ‘single-handed’ (independently), 19 experienced pain complaints. There was also a group of 15 dentists who, according to the situation, worked ‘two- or four-handed” (with the help of an assistant), and 10 of them complained of pain in the cervical region of the spine (Figure 2).
The smallest number of dentists aged over 60 worked using the ‘single-handed’ technique. The ‘four-handed’ or ‘two- and four-handed’ methods were applied mainly by dentists aged 30–45 and over 60 years. However, these data are statistically insignificant (Pearson’s χ2 test for independence p = 0.05660).
The investigation of the duration of breaks at work of dentists showed that the majority of them (61.5%) devoted from 5 to 15 min to rest. It is an interesting fact that 12 respondents did not use any break while performing occupational activity, mainly those aged under 45 years (Table 1).
As many as 29 (55.8%) dentists in the study declared that they often assume a very non-ergonomic position at work, 21 (40.4%) assumed this position only sometimes, while the remaining 2 physicians (3.8%) never assumed this position.
As many as 14 respondents performed simple relaxation exercises during breaks at work, and 11 dentists participated in extra courses that made them aware of the risk of loading the musculoskeletal system at work. More than a half of the respondents (28) had not participated in the courses and did not perform exercises during breaks. A statistically significant relationship was found between the performance of exercises during breaks at work and participation in extra courses (Pearson’s χ2 test for independence, p = 0.00066) (Figure 3).
No relationship was observed between cervical spine pain and the age of physicians in the study (p = 0.05801). Pain complaints were reported by 14 dentists (26.9%) in the group aged 30–45 years, 9 (17.3%) in the group aged 46–60 and over, and 5 (9.6%) among those aged under 30. Summing up, as many as 37 respondents (71.1%) experienced pain in the cervical region of the spine.
A statistically significant relationship was noted between pain in the cervical region of the spine and duration of performance of the occupation of a dentist (p = 0.01122). The results of the study showed (Figure 4) that all respondents (100%) who had a period of employment of more than 31 years (11) experienced pain complaints; 15 (75%) per 20 dentists with the period of employment 5–15 years experienced pain in the cervical region of the spine, as well as 7 (70%) who had work experience of 15–30 years. In the group of respondents who had a period of employment up to 5 years only 4 (36.3%) complained of pain.
The intensity of pain in the cervical region of the spine changed from the moment of undertaking occupational activity until the end of a workday. At the beginning of the day, 36 (69.2%) respondents did not experience pain, whereas after its completion – only 10 (19.2%) experienced pain. Mild pain was reported by 14 respondents (26.9%), and at the end of the workday, by 27 (51.9%) respondents. Severe pain was mentioned by 2 respondents (3.8%), and at completion of work, by 14 (26.9%) respondents. Severe pain after work occurred in only one respondent.
Considering cervical pain, the number of workdays, and the age of the dentists in the study a relationship was noted, which was close to statistical significance (p = 0.05121). In the group of 15 dentists who worked less than 5 days a week, as many as 14 ex­perienced pain, mainly those aged over 46 years (Table 2).
As many as 40.4% of dentists described presently experienced pain in the cervical region of the spine as blunt and disseminated, 34.6% – as radiating, and only 3.8% – as acute.
According to 48.1% of respondents, pain complaints are caused by long-lasting static body position; 23.1% of them considered that kinesitherapeutic exercises alleviate pain complaints concerning the cervical region of the spine; and 28.8% of dentists took analgesic drugs or combined them with exercises according to the McKenzi method (19.2%). In 42.3% of respondents the treatment brought about the expected outcome.
In 14 respondents, apart from pain in the neck section of the spine, they also described pain in the lumbosacral region, and 2 respondents experienced pain in the cervical thoracic, lumbar, and sacral sections (Table 3).
The dentists also complain of dizziness during work (3.8%), shoulder pain (15.4%), and wrist pain (17.3%). These symptoms occurred separately or together (21.2%). Due to the high risk of overload and degenerative changes, more than a half of the respondents (67.3%) attached importance to prophylactic examinations.
Among the respondents, currently experienced pain in the cervical region of mediocre intensity was reported by 20 dentists (38.5%), 16 (30.8%) evaluated the intensity of pain as low, only 1 (1.9%) as high, while 15 respondents (28.8%) did not mention any pain (acc. to VAS).
The results of a modified pain assessment questionnaire according to Laitinen indicated that 30 respondents (57.7%) experienced mild pain, occurring periodically, which did not cause limitation of locomotor activity. Nearly 20% of respondents did not experience pain (10), and 11 (21.2%) perceived pain as severe. Only 15 dentists (28.8%) did not apply analgesics, and 30 took these drugs occasionally; 34.6% (18) declared partial limitation of locomotor activity due to pain.

Discussion

There is an increasing amount of evidence that the unique work conditions in dentistry may exert a considerable effect on the health of physicians. The results of a survey conducted in a group of 1,670 Lithuanian dentists showed that the majority of them (80.8%) considered their occupation as physically demanding, 16.9% of respondents partially agree with this, and approximately 2.3% entirely disagreed with such a statement. More than a half of respondents (50.4%) described their state of health as satisfactory, and 46.6% as good or very good. The minority, only 3.4% of respondents, evaluated their state of health as very good, while 3% as poor or very bad [12].
Dentists usually perform their occupation in a standing and sitting position. Strojek et al. [13] reported that in a group of 20 respondents, the largest number, i.e. a half of them, worked in the above-mentioned positions. The preferred patient position was the prone position [14, 15]. The majority of a group of 140 dentists in South Arabia, as many as 95 (67.9%), when asked to describe their standing position in terms of the hands on a clock, described assuming a position between the hours of 10:00 and 12:00 on the clock face, the centre of which is placed at the height of the patient’s mouth. Dentists who worked at the 09:00 position reported more complaints (76.5%) than those working at the 10:00 position (48.3%). Only 17 respondents worked at the 12:00 position and mentioned complaints concerning the neck and back [14].
The majority of dentists in the examined group (42) possessed modern, electrically adjustable equipment, which enabled assumption of the correct body posture. Tuszyński and Lella consider that implementation of modern equipment of the unit type, with an ergonomic seat for the dentist, prone position for the patient, and an adjustable bolster, facilitates the performance of procedures and reduces overload of the neck muscles and cervical spine of the physician [15].
Bladowski et al. consider that a physician who works in a team shares 35–60% of the activities performed with assistants, compared to performing work by the solo method [3]. According to reports, the most advantageous method of work is the ‘four-handed’ or ‘six-handed’ technique, because with such an organisation of work the load is distributed among 2–3 persons. Unfortunately, the results of the survey demonstrated that less than 1% of Polish dentists work ‘four-handed’. Not a single physician was found who would work by the ‘six-handed’ technique [15], a technique that is new in Poland and unwillingly practiced due to economic reasons [16]. The studies carried out in South Arabia indicated that as many as 89% of the dentists examined work by the ‘four-handed’ method [14].
The long working time of many physicians, which is even more than 10 h daily, results in excessive exhaustion of the body [7]. The results of our own studies show that 23.1% of respondents do not take any breaks while performing occupational activity.
The specificity of profession requires from dentists the assumption of a forced body position at work. According to Lewczuk et al., dentists remain in a leaning position for approximately 30–50% of their working time. In addition, they perform from 100–300 bends, and from 800–1000 repeated movements of the upper extremities, from full bend to upright [1]. The results of our own studies show that from among 52 respondents as many as 29 (55.8%) very frequently assume non-ergonomic positions.
Musculoskeletal pain has been considered as a serious health problem among dentists; hence, there are many studies describing these complaints [17]. In a group of 20 respondents, as many as 16 (80%) had shallow cervical lordosis. In addition, an abnormal positioning was noted of the head and neck (70%), shoulders (85%), and waist triangles (90%). An increased tension of the paraspinal muscles in the neck section was observed in 8 respondents (40%). Pathological changes begin early, i.e. in the neck section after 11 years, in the lumbar section after 13 years, and in both sections simultaneously after 15 years [13]. Degenerative changes in the neck section of the spine cause limitation of all movements on both sides of the spine. Greater limitations occur on the painful side, and concern mainly the rotation of the spine towards the painful side (46.9%) [4].
The results of the presented study indicate that the duration of performing the occupation exerts an effect on the occurrence of pain in the cervical region of the spine in dentists. In Queensland, Australia a survey was conducted which confirmed that 248 dentists (87.2%) had experienced at least one symptom of musculoskeletal disorders within the last 12 months. Complaints concerning the neck were most often reported (57.5%). It is an interesting fact that pain in this region more frequently occurred in young respondents, who had less professional experience. More than one third of all dentists (37.5%) sought advice or had undertaken treatment within the last 12 months [18]. Lithuanian physicians aged 34 and under evaluated their state of health as satisfactory (24.6%), while some of them (1.3%) evaluated it as poor or very bad. Physical disorders may occur at the beginning of a dental career, especially among students. These facts emphasise the importance of paying attention to health as soon as during university studies, and becoming familiar with the principles of ergonomics, early diagnostics, and treatment of profession-related diseases [12]. The presented study showed that 14 dentists (26.9%) perceived pain complaints in the cervical, lumbar, or sacral sections of the spine. In two respondents pain occurred in the cervical, thoracic, lumbar, and sacral sections. Presently experienced cervical spine pain was described as: blunt and diffused (40.4%), radiating (34.6%), and acute (3.8%).
Strojek et al. [13] reported that the use of complex and integrated rehabilitation (massage, kinesitherapy, paraffin, Sollux lamp, Terapuls device, ultrasound, diadynamic current, galvanic current, cryotherapy) resulted in an improvement in 14 respondents (70%), while in 6 (30%) no improvement was noted. The results of the presented study indicate that in order to decrease pain in the cervical region of the spine 15 (28.8%) dentists in the study took analgesics or combined them with exercises according to the McKenzie method (19.2%). In 22 dentists (42.3%) the treatment procedures brought about the expected outcomes.
Also psychosocial factors, such as tension, rush, responsibility, and complexity of work and its intensity, may affect the occurrence of pain complaints on the part of the musculoskeletal system [7]. There is a relationship between the occurrence of chronic cervical spine pain syndrome, and depression, and experiencing emotions such as fear, anxiety, concern, or humiliation [19].

Conclusions

Dentists possess knowledge concerning the principles of ergonomics, which they should use while performing their occupation. A statistically significant difference was observed between the period of performance of the occupation of a dentist and occurrence of pain in the cervical region of the spine. No statistically significant relationship was found between age and the technique of performing work by a dentist in the group in the survey. No statistically significant difference was noted between working time during the week and occurrence of pain in the cervical region of the spine in the examined group. Dentists pay great attention to the prophylaxis of diseases of the locomotor organ.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

1. Lewczuk E, Affelska-Jercha A, Tomczyk J. Zawodowe zagrożenia zdrowotne w gabinetach stomatologicznych. Medycyna Pracy 2002; 53: 161-5.
2. Krawczyk-Adamus P, Pałczyński C. Wpływ pracy zawodowej na układ ruchu lekarzy stomatologów. Twój Przegląd Stomatologiczny 2005; 11: 48-50.
3. Bladowski M, Bogdan M, Kołakowska-Woźniczka B, et al. Wstęp do ergonomii pracy w stomatologii ogólnej. Magazyn Stomatologiczny 2001; 1: 10-4.
4. Barczyk K, Skolimowski T, Jasiński R, et al. Wpływ zmian zwyrodnieniowych kręgosłupa szyjnego na zaburzenia czynnościowe narządu ruchu kobiet w średnim wieku. Fizjoterapia 2006; 14: 53-8.
5. Bladowski M. Stomatologia zachowawcza w znieczuleniu ogólnym. Tryb ambulatoryjny. Podstawy ergonomii pracy zespołu stomatologicznego i zasady zespołowych technik pracy podczas zabiegów wykonywanych w znieczuleniu ogólnym. Nowa Stomatologia 2002; 2: 73-87.
6. Skomro P, Opalko K, Szumiłowicz P. Nowe zadania dla higienistki stomatologicznej w gabinecie. Asystentka i Higienistka Stomatologiczna 2006; 1: 46-7.
7. Piątkowska A, Szymańska J. Choroby zawodowe i parazawodowe układu ruchu u stomatologów. Zdrowie Publiczne 2009; 119: 228-30.
8. Szubert Z, Sobala W. Czasowa niezdolność do pracy osób z przewlekłymi chorobami narządu ruchu wywołanymi sposobem wykonywania pracy. Medycyna Pracy 2001; 52: 87-94.
9. Laitinen J. Acupuncture and transcutaneus electric stimulation in the treatment of chronic sacrolumbalgia and ischialgia. Am J Chin Med 1976; 4: 169-75.
10. Depa A, Wolan A, Przysada G. Wpływ rehabilitacji na zmianę ruchomości kręgosłupa z zespołem bólowym w odcinku lędźwiowym. Przegląd Medyczny Uniwersytetu Rzeszowskiego 2008; 2: 116-24.
11. Krysicki W, Bartos J, Dyczka W, et al. Rachunek prawdopodobieństwa i statystyka matematyczna w zadaniach. Cz. 2. Statystyka matematyczna. Wyd. 8. PWN, Warsaw 2006.
12. Puriene A, Aleksejuniene J, Petrauskiene J, et al. Self-reported occupational health issues among Lithuanian dentists. Industrial Health 2008; 46: 369-74.
13. Strojek K, Bułatowicz I, Chilimoniuk K, et al. Nieergonomiczna praca stomatologów jedną z przyczyn rozwoju zmian zwyrodnieniowo-zniekształcających kręgosłupa. Collegium Medicum UMK w Bydgoszczy, Bydgoszcz 2009; 378-83.
14. Abduljabbar T. Musculoskeletal disorders among dentists in Saudi Arabia. Pakistan Oral and Dental 2008; 28: 135-44.
15. Tuszyński K, Lella A. Choroby zawodowe lekarzy stomatologów. Via Medica, Gdańsk 2009.
16. Tananis S, Goczewski M, Bladowski M, Wysokińska-Miszczuk J. Analiza obciążeń układu nerwowego i mięśniowo-szkieletowego u operatorów w stomatologii pracujących w mikroskopie operacyjnym. As Stomatologii 2008; 6: 26-30.
17. Leggat P, Kedjerune U, Smith D. Occupational health problems in modern dentistry: a review. Industrial Health 2007; 45: 611-21.
18. Leggat P, Smith D. Musculoskeletal disorders self-reported by dentists in Queensland, Australia. Aust Dent J 2006; 51: 324-7.
19. Szczygieł E, Krzanik B, Golec J, Szot P. Rola czynników psychologicznych w przewlekłych zespołach bólowych kręgosłupa szyjnego. Fizjoter Pol 2009; 4: 312-20.

Address for correspondence:

Jędrzej Płocki MD
Szpital Specjalistyczny im. Świętej Rodziny
Rudna Mała 600, 36-060 Głogów Młp.
Phone: +48 17 866 67 00
E-mail: jplocki@gazeta.pl
Copyright: © 2015 Jan Kochanowski University in Kielce This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/), allowing third parties to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format and to remix, transform, and build upon the material, provided the original work is properly cited and states its license.
facebook linkedin twitter
© 2022 Termedia Sp. z o.o. All rights reserved.
Developed by Bentus.